Google Maps Loses San Antonio Tx - Eaten by a "Shitty" One Box

Linda Buquet

Moderator
Joined
Jun 28, 2012
Messages
14,438
One of our most eagle-eyed members, Ryan AKA Optmize Prime spotted a little problem on Google Maps and posted last night.

Search Google Maps for "San Antonio Tx". The city is nowhere to be found.

In it's place... a shitty ONE BOX! The bane of my existence!

A business called "San Antonio Car Carrier" - has the whole city locked up!


San Antonio Lost

SanAntonioLost.jpg



As Ryan pointed out searching for directions is futile, because Google can't find the city.


San+Antonio+Google+Maps.JPG


Same thing happens on a regular Google search for San Antonio Tx. You get that single pinned result for "San Antonio Car Carrier".

Mike Blumenthal, myself and others have been trying to push Google to change the shitty algo that wrongly triggers a branded one box for a generic term and locks every other business in that city out of the 7 pack - for almost 6 months!

I 1st reported this 8/2013, and Mike has posted several times since:
Attack of the Bad Google Local One-Boxes!
Hummingbird, Local Knowledge Graph & Shitty Search Results
Mining for Google Hummingbird Guano in So Cal
Google Local: Hummingbird Diarrhea Persists 6 Months On

Maybe now that a one box ate an entire major metro, Google will finally see that part of the algo is cranked too damn high!

If you Google "San Antonio Car Carrier" "(830) 469-7600" (the name as listed on the Place page) there are ZERO matches, but the real DBA is plural and has only 17 matches on Google, so it's not like it's a strong listing or uber big brand! :eek:

I suspect it's a bug that caused this particular maps problem. TX is repeated twice in the address, so maybe that's what did it? Hidden address on the listing is entered as "New Territories, San Antonio TX, TX"

Thanks again to eagle eye Ryan. Here is his original post:
Did Google Maps misplace San Antonio, TX?



 

Motorwiz

Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2012
Messages
5
In the meantime, Yelp keeps appearing at the top 3 - 5 top organic results and above the 7 pack. Search Google for auto repair San Diego - auto repair Los Angeles - auto repair San Jose and you'll see. They couldn't buy Yelp back in 2009, and instead of helping SMBs with local, they let Yelp become the behemoth that it is now.

When I used to suggest our clients to concentrate on getting reviews in G+ local, now most of them are flocking to Yelp. Spite of their "review filtering algo BS", they gladly pay the $300-$500/Mo., because they think that it's the only way that their good reviews will count.
 

Weekly Digest

Weekly Digest
Subscribe/Unsubscribe

Trending: Most Viewed

Promoted Posts

New advertising option: A review of your product or service posted by a Sterling Sky employee. This will also be shared on the Sterling Sky & LSF Twitter accounts, our Facebook group, LinkedIn, and both newsletters. More...

Local Search Forum


Google Product Exert

@LocalSearchLink

Join Our Facebook Group

Top